Monday, November 16, 2026AboutTipsSubscribe free
Media Mogul News
INDEPENDENT. UNBOUGHT. UNAFRAID.
LATEST
National

Supreme Court Strikes Down the Birthright Citizenship Order in a 6 to 3 Landmark

Chief Justice Roberts anchors the ruling in the 14th Amendment and 128 years of precedent while Alito calls it a serious mistake.

Supreme Court Strikes Down the Birthright Citizenship Order in a 6 to 3 Landmark

The Supreme Court has struck down President Trump's executive order ending birthright citizenship, ruling 6 to 3 on June 30 in Trump v. Barbara that children born on American soil are citizens at birth, no matter the immigration status of their parents.

Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the majority opinion, with Justice Kavanaugh concurring in the judgment only. Roberts traced birthright citizenship to English common law and held that the framers of the 14th Amendment intended to permanently enshrine that principle in the Constitution after the infamy of Dred Scott. The majority reaffirmed the 1898 precedent of Wong Kim Ark, concluding that the Citizenship Clause incorporated the common law and granted citizenship to nearly all children born in the United States.

Under the Constitution, they are citizens at birth, Roberts wrote. Citizenship, he added, was and is the right to have rights, the ticket to full participation in our political community.

Get the stories they're afraid to run — free. Join the newsletter →

The dissents came out swinging. Justice Alito, joined by others, called the ruling a serious mistake about the true meaning of the 14th Amendment. Justice Thomas dissented separately, joined by Justice Gorsuch, and Gorsuch added a brief dissent of his own. The dissenters pressed the argument that the amendment's phrase about being subject to the jurisdiction of the United States was never meant to cover the children of those here unlawfully. The majority rejected the related theory that domicile should determine citizenship.

Let us be straight with our readers, because plenty of them wanted this order upheld. The frustration behind it is legitimate. Birth tourism is real, the border catastrophe of the last decade was real, and the incentive structure created by automatic citizenship is worth debating. No honest person denies that.

But here is the constitutionalist's answer, and it is the one this Court just gave. If Americans want to change the meaning of the 14th Amendment, there is a lawful way to do it, and it is called Article V. It requires persuading your fellow citizens, not signing an order. Conservatives spent fifty years arguing that the Constitution means what it says even when the outcome is inconvenient. That principle does not come with an exceptions clause for our team.

There is also a silver lining worth naming. This ruling came from a Court with three Trump appointed justices, which rather complicates the tired narrative that the judiciary is a rubber stamp. These justices call them as they see them, against presidents of both parties. That independence is precisely what conservatives fought to build.

The administration keeps its wins on enforcement, deportations, and the border, where the record is historic. On this question, the Constitution said no. In a republic worth keeping, that has to be the end of the argument.

Sources

Questions readers ask

What is Media Mogul News?

Media Mogul News is an independent, reader-supported news site led by Chief Editor Nate Jurewicz. We cover the stories corporate media skips: political corruption, Big Pharma, the deep state, election integrity, cannabis freedom, crypto and the money behind all of it.

What is your political stance?

We are pro-liberty, pro-cannabis, anti-war and anti-corruption, and we hold both parties to the same standard. We are not a party outlet. When the people we agree with get something wrong, we say so.

How is Media Mogul funded?

By readers. We take no pharmaceutical advertising and no money from the industries we cover. Support comes from newsletter readers, donations and Media Mogul merchandise.